You probably don’t need statistics or anecdotal evidence to point out that the argument over whether Fernando Tatis Jr. broke some antiquated dumb unwritten baseball rules by hitting home run on a 3-0 pitch with the bases loaded late in a game in which his San Diego Padres are up by seven runs.
Heck, you already have Major Leaguers — included some former ones who are Hall of Famers — defending Tatis, as they should.
But there are MLB fans and writers on Twitter who are noting how hypocritical this whole absurd business is.
Let’s start with this: the number of times home runs have been hit on 3-0 counts with a big lead, some of which come late in games:
Since detailed pitch data became available in 1988, there have been 16 instances of a homer being hit in a 3-0 count with a 6+ run lead…within the list are 25 All-Star appearances, 8 Silver Slugger Awards, 2 MVP Awards and 1 World Series MVP (h/t @baseball_ref ) pic.twitter.com/BTXvljsMNT
— Patrick Kurish (@PKurish) August 18, 2020
Were Robin Ventura, Jay Buhner, Tony Batista (twice!!), Juan Gonzalez, Hideki Matsui, Manny Machado et al thrown at or called out for breaking the rules?
And then there’s this moment from last year in which the Rangers were called out for breaking unwritten rules, when they were managed by Chris Woodward, the very same manager who said “I didn’t like it, personally” about Tatis’s homer?
The Rangers let a pop fly drop so Mike Minor could get to 200 strikeouts:
The Rangers intentionally let a popup drop in the 9th inning so Mike Minor could have another shot at notching his 200th strikeout of the season.
Minor recorded that strikeout on the next pitch he threw. pic.twitter.com/nMqeTa2PJo
— ESPN (@espn) September 26, 2019
Maybe Woodward’s experiences have something to do with why he’s somehow against late grand slams in blowouts.
Those games …
7/9/05: 11-4 PIT win vs. NYM*
8/28/04: 18-6 NYY win vs. TOR*
7/10/04: 11-2 ANA win vs. TOR*
5/16/02: 15-2 SEA win vs. TOR*
9/24/99: 18-4 CLE win vs. TOR**Woodward's team
He did not play in a 19-7 SEA win vs. TOR* on 4/16/00, which also featured such a slam.
— Jason Catania (@JayCat11) August 18, 2020
Whatever it is, it’s all ridiculous, especially when you look at all of this.
[jwplayer 3MJy1e76-q2aasYxh]