#5. Jay Cutler (2017)
Passing Yards: 2,666 (19 touchdowns)
Cutler was called upon by Adam Gase in 2017 when Ryan Tannehill went down with a knee injury in training camp to keep the Dolphins competitive. It didn’t work. Cutler went 6-8 as the starter but Miami’s passing offense was as punchless an attack as you’ll find in the NFL.