The playoffs can’t come soon enough for the Lions as the defense is running low on players to even limp to the finish line. Multiple defenders went down vs the Bills including two key starters in Alim McNeill and Carlton Davis.
Postgame, Dan Campbell delivered pessimistic outlooks on those two: “We’ll know more [Monday], I don’t feel good about either one of those guys… for the rest of the year.”
Definitively lost for the season is Khalil Dorsey who is a valuable backup CB and special teams player.
Here are the injuries seen on initial look including suspected diagnoses:
Carlton Davis – jaw 1q 12:30 & 2q 13:29
In the 1st quarter, Davis took a shot to the left side of the helmet during a tackle and was out for one play. In the 2nd quarter, video is obscured but you can presume that he took a blow to the left side of his head again. Afterwards, trainers are seen checking out his left jaw area, and he did not return to the game.
Carlton Davis jaw injury video
-Came out 2x, maybe related
-In 1st qtr, blow to L head. Grabs facemask after. Returned after 1 play.
-In 2nd qtr, presumably hits L head on tackle. Trainers looking at L jaw. Did not return. pic.twitter.com/GDcwYFURVv— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
This wouldn’t be the first time this year that Davis has taken trauma to the left side of his head. Back in Week 6, a cleat hit the left side of his helmetless head. It’s uncertain if all these injuries are related.
Not the first game this year Carlton Davis has taken a wicked blow to the left side of head. This happened back in week 6. pic.twitter.com/W1eTXuISAE
— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
David Montgomery – right knee 2q 7:39
It’s not clear when the injury happened. The suspicious play is when he got his right leg tangled up at the end of a run. The next carry after that, it appeared his right leg gave out on him. He stayed in another play before leaving for the rest of the half.
Montgomery returned to start the 3rd quarter with a visible right knee wrap. He was able to play into the 4th quarter and looked fine doing so. After the game, Dan Campbell stated he’s “a little banged up”. Hopefully, this is just a mild knee sprain or contusion and nothing unexpected shows up on MRI.
David Montgomery R knee injury video
-Unclear moment of injury
-1st clip is suspicious play when leg gets tangled up. Stayed in.
-Next carry R leg appears to give out
-Returned after halftime with knee wrap and finished game. No sig concern but worth watching. pic.twitter.com/9wM2BOLmOD— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
Khalil Dorsey – right tibia and fibula fracture near the ankle 2q 1:47
Dorsey will be out for the season. His fracture is similar to Aidan Hutchinson’s except Dorsey’s appears to be lower down the leg and closer to the ankle joint. It was officially listed as an ankle. Thus, there is concern for joint damage here which potentially makes it a more complicated injury than Hutchinson’s which spared the joint. Dorsey will be an unrestricted free agent this offseason.
Khalil Dorsey R ankle fracture injury video
-Likely tib/fib close to ankle joint
-Out for year
-Hope the joint damage is minimal as that could complicate recovery pic.twitter.com/89Y0N51j57— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
Interestingly, Dorsey was at high risk for the same injury last year when he made a tripping tackle on kick coverage. The impact force on that play last year looked much greater than the one that broke his leg this year. This epitomizes the fluky nature of many NFL injuries.
Khalil Dorsey L leg injury video
-Impossible to see in real time but slomo can see tripping mechanism
-This is why tripping is a penalty. Easily could have broken own leg.
-Appears to clear Lachman ACL test
-Presumably has dodged serious knee/ankle injury but will be sore pic.twitter.com/rY03MOsCqS— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) November 2, 2023
Alim McNeill – right knee 3q 7:20
Video was not obvious here. It’s not clear exactly which step he hurt his knee but suspecting it was the final step when he comes down hard on a straight leg. Best case scenario would be a mild bone bruise or knee sprain. Meniscus damage is a possibility. Worst cases are an ACL or a fracture. We should know the prognosis very soon.
Alim McNeill R knee injury video
-Uncertain on which step injury occurred but suspicion for final step landing hard on straight leg
-Postgame pessimism is concerning for ACL
-Best case would be mild bone bruise. Also possible are meniscus or other knee sprain. pic.twitter.com/RYYMkaigPt— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
Terrion Arnold – passed concussion evaluation 4q 14:00
Arnold went up high to defend a pass and landed hard on his back causing his head to whiplash onto the turf. This easily could have caused a concussion, but he presumably passed the evaluation and finished out the game. Delayed symptoms are unlikely but possible, and we should know that by the first practice on Wednesday.
Terrion Arnold concussion eval video
-Skies to knock down pass but lands hard on back and head bounces off turf
-No signs of concussion on vid.
-Presumably passed concussion eval and finished out game
-Hope no delayed symptoms pic.twitter.com/PAyPLKfU60— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024
Brian Branch – right upper leg strain 4q 4:12
This is the second time in two games that Branch has reached for his right upper lateral leg area after a tackle. He did this last week vs the Packers also. In each instance, he was awkwardly bent over to the side while making the tackle.
He was able to stay in the game both times, but there may be a mild underlying injury that he has been battling through. A muscle/tendon or iliotibial band strain are possible.
Brian Branch R upper leg injury video
-He’s playing thru something as this is 2nd time in past 2 games he has reached for this area. Both times, bent sideways during tackle.
-Able to finish game.
-Suspect muscle/tendon or iliotibial band strain pic.twitter.com/V4379VEL34— Jimmy Liao MD | Detroit Lions Morning Rounds (@JimmyLiaoMD) December 16, 2024