Packers Wire recently unveiled the ultimate Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers Green Bay Packers team featuring the best players from the era (1992-2022) of the two legendary quarterbacks.
Now, it’s time for competition. Favre vs. Rodgers. Which quarterback had the better era in Green Bay?
First, some (remarkably close) numbers. Between 1992 and 2007, Favre’s Packers were 161-95 in the regular season (.629, first in NFL) and 12-10 playoffs (second-most wins). Between 2008 and 2022, Rodgers’ Packers were 153-87-2 (.636, second) and 11-10 playoffs (tied third for wins).
Both teams won a Super Bowl: Favre’s Packers won Super Bowl XXXI, Rodgers’ Rodgers won Super Bowl XLV.
Favre’s Packers won seven NFC Central or NFC North titles and went to four NFC title games (2-2); Rodgers’ Packers won eight division titles and went to five NFC title games (1-4).
Which quarterback had the better teams and more talent around them?
Let’s dive into the 53-player teams for the era of Favre and the era of Rodgers, position-by-position. Determining a winner between the two teams is up to you.