WR Derrick Mason
OK, Derrick Mason was named to the Pro Bowl. He was named to two actually, following the 2000 and 2003 seasons. But these were as a member of the Tennesse Titans. During his time with the Ravens between 2005-2010, Mason did not earn a return to the all-star game.
This is slightly noteworthy, as while Mason was never the best wide receiver in the game during this span, he was still pretty consistent. He had four seasons with more than 1,000 receiving yards, and only six wide receivers had more receptions than his 471 in this span. Mason had the 11th-most receiving yards among all wide receivers between 2005-2010. But he only scored 29 touchdowns, tied for 25th most.
Mason was a solid player for the Ravens, but just clearing 1,000 receiving yards in the increasingly pass-happy league he was playing in just wasn’t enough to attract the attention of the Pro Bowl voters.