Scott Hunter — 1971
6th round, 140th pick, Packers
The Packers might have thought they were getting the next Bart Starr when the drafted fellow alumnus Hunter out of Alabama. But it was hard for Hunter to live up to the legend. Though he helped lead the 1972 Packers to the franchise’s last divisional title until the Brett Favre era, Hunter was never a true difference maker. He later moved onto the Bills and Falcons and finished his eight-year career with 23 touchdown passes and 38 interceptions.