Navigating your 2023 fantasy football draft

you can make intelligent decisions about how to pursue the positions that make up your optimal roster.

Navigating your 2023 fantasy football draft

It’s time to prepare the path to your fantasy league championship. Fortunately, the torrent of hype and hope surrounding each player means that each draft shares an amazing similarity in who goes where. You may not reach the exact player you want at a certain spot, but you can make intelligent decisions about how to pursue the positions that make up your optimal roster.

Kickers and team defenses rightfully belong to the final rounds, but where can you gain advantages in for 2023 draft? Like most years, fantasy teams constantly grab running backs and wideouts, but what will you do at quarterback and tight end? Those positions only provide one fantasy starter.  No amount of mixing and matching those position will result in what just one elite player provides all year. And they are highly reliable players at the top.

Syndication: Arizona Republic

Quarterbacks – Top quarterbacks score the most of any position in most leagues. And the position is showing up earlier in drafts in recent years. The Top-3 from last year – Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Jalen Hurts – are the first signal callers taken this year.  Mahomes and Allen have been Top-10 for the last four years and each have a couple of No. 1 finishes in that time. Hurts is a newcomer to the elite tier and is reasonably expected to remain. Expect all three to be gone by the third round and either Mahomes or Allen may cost a second round.

The next three may not win your league, but they won’t be why you lost it. That includes Joe Burrow, Justin Herbert, and Lamar Jackson who have all reached Top-5 in previous years and they’ll go by the fifth or sixth rounds to those looking for at least a small advantage. If you are the sort that waits on the position, at least go for the higher upside of Justin Fields, Daniel Jones, Trevor Lawrence, or Deshaun Watson by the end of the ninth round. And if you’ve historically waited on the position, how’s that worked out for you? Maybe it is expensive, but owning one of the top fantasy scorers in your league is always an advantage.

Credit: Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Running Backs – This is the year of opportunity for running backs. And for tremendous risk. Do you feel lucky? Aside from Christian McCaffrey and Austin Ekeler taken in the first five picks, there’s much less consensus than ever with the position. These NFL players are devalued despite the out-sized contributions to their offense. That’s caused an unprecedented number of holdouts, “hold-ins”, talented free agents, unhappy franchise tags and major question marks in at least half of the backfields.  The best rusher from each NFL team can last into the seventh round.

The NFL may be a passing league, but the player with the most touches is always the primary running back. Fantasy leaguers respond to this dilemma by loading up on top wide receivers initially and then sorting through the remaining bin of running backs. You can expect four to six teams owning no more than one running back at the start of the fifth round. In the fourth round, you’ll still reach players like Aaron Jones, Joe Mixon, Kenneth Walker, and Miles Sanders.  In most leagues, James Conner, Alvin Kamara, Isaiah Pacheco and Alexander Mattison will finally get drafted by the end of the seventh round.

Given the uncertainty, 2023 is a good season for loading up on the lowest risk options for all positions, and taking your chances with running backs from rounds four to seven. There will be some incredible values in drafts for your backfield once it is all settled and players lock into who they are and where they play. And yet a ton of risk until they do.

Credit: Chuck Cook-USA TODAY Sports

Wide Receivers – This is the year of the wideout. While the number taken in the first two rounds isn’t up dramatically, opening the draft with Justin Jefferson and Ja’Marr Chase is a new twist for fantasy leagues that historically start with the prior year’s best running backs. But wide receivers command at least half of the picks made in the first two rounds. At least three or four teams start with two wideouts before considering another position and those elite pass catches offer consistent and reliable fantasy points.

Only one of the Top-10 running backs of 2021 repeated that standing last year (Austin Ekeler). All others failed to repeat a difference-making year. For wideouts, about half of them repeated. Jefferson, Tyreek Hill, Davante Adams, and Stefon Diggs all recorded their third straight Top-10 performance.

You can expect at least five wideouts per round to be drafted. There are no big values in the position because they’ve become the new “running backs” in fantasy drafts – highly coveted and stripped of the Top-30 by the end of the sixth round. The top rookies of 2021 are gone by the fourth round – Garrett Wilson, Chris Olave, and Drake London. Receivers are also made more reliable because in those first thirty, only DeAndre Hopkins and Calvin Ridley are playing on different teams this year. If you get rattled and need to make a quick pick, grab the best available wideout.

Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

Tight Ends – Yes, it is the lowest scoring skill position and you need to decide if you want to pay the price for a difference-maker. Travis Kelce’s monster 2021 means that once the Top-3 wide receivers and running backs are taken, he’s usually the next to be drafted. There’s no other fantasy player that dominates his position like Kelce. If receptions points are involved, Kelce is a steal beyond that No. 7 overall pick.

There is still an advantage in owning a top tight end. Consider the rounds where value is drained – Mark Andrews (3), T.J. Hockenson (4), George Kittle (5), Dallas Goedert (6), and Kyle Pitts (6).  Beyond that, at least look for upside with Evan Engram, Darren Waller, or David Njoku are all well situated to improve on their 2021 production.

How confident should you be in drafting Jonathan Taylor?

Could a new coaching staff and QB negatively impact Taylor in 2023?

There are few things that destroy fantasy teams like using the first overall pick on a player who is either injured or has a steep decline in production. In the case of Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor, you had both.

Taylor came into 2022 as the consensus No. 1 overall fantasy pick due to one of the greatest running back seasons of recent history in 2021. He made a case to be the league MVP, rushing for 1,811 yards, catching 40 passes for 360 yards and scoring 20 touchdowns. However, injuries, a struggling offensive line, and poor quarterback play resulted in Taylor’s production dropping considerably – by his standards.

In his first two seasons, Taylor averaged 5.3 yards a carry. That number dropped to 4.5 yards last season – a solid average for most backs, but a step backward for Taylor. Most telling was that his touchdown total dropped from 20 to four, which left fantasy players empty-handed more weeks than not. However, the blame can’t be pinned solely on Taylor, who missed games in October, November, December and January due to ankle injuries. There were other contributing factors that led to his decline.

The Colts had injuries on the offensive line last season and struggled at left tackle positions as they transitioned to a new starter. The biggest issue may have been aging quarterback Matt Ryan. He was a glacier in the pocket and defenses didn’t have to prepare for him in the run game. Colts quarterbacks were sacked 60 times last season, because teams could bring pressure that not only reached the quarterback but flooded running lanes for Taylor as there was no threat of diversity in the Colts’ rushing attack. That has changed a lot over the last six months.

[lawrence-related id=477502]

Ryan and Nick Foles are gone. The team drafted versatile Anthony Richardson to be the new franchise quarterback and signed veteran Gardner Minshew to be a placeholder in the event Richardson needs time to get the call to be the starter.

The Colts made numerous changes on offense in their coaching staff, bringing in people with success in elevating young quarterbacks. Head coach Shane Steichen was the offensive coordinator for the Philadelphia Eagles, where not only did he oversee the ascent of Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia had the league’s most productive running games the last two seasons. Offensive coordinator Jim Bob Cooter helped Trevor Lawrence have a breakout second season after a rough start in Jacksonville. Quarterbacks coach Cam Turner worked to get Kyler Murray prepared for the NFL in Arizona. All three of these coaches were instrumental in quickly elevating young quarterbacks in the NFL and taking advantage of their versatility as passers and runners. The same can be expected with Richardson and, in the process, give Taylor more opportunities as defenses need to be on their heels to prepare for RPO formations.

Fantasy football outlook

Those who invested in Taylor last year will likely view him as poisonous, but the offseason changes only bolster the idea that Taylor can return to form and be the most productive workhorse back in the league. He will probably slide down a handful of spots in the draft, but he is healthy after offseason ankle surgery, has little competition, is entering the final year of his rookie contract and has two Pro Bowl interior offensive linemen in front of him.

The only serious concern right now is whether the mobile Richardson will steal enough rushing touchdowns to lower Taylor’s ceiling.

It’s hard to say that someone who will likely still be a top-five draft pick could be a value pick, but Taylor has all the incentive he needs to bounce back and make things difficult for the Colts not to give him a second contract.

Fantasy football draft prep: 12 common mistakes to avoid

A dozen rules fantasy footballers must follow for consistent success.

Our annual “draft prep” series mostly caters to novice players, but every once in a while a veteran player requires a refresher on basics we may take for granted.

These rules are in no particular order, and they apply to all levels of experience among fantasy owners. Just as important as the “what you should do” to create a winner in fantasy drafting, avoiding simple pitfalls is a must.

[lawrence-related id=467551]

Fantasy Football: 10 utilization stats to know from Week 2

Here are the utilization stats you should know from Week 2 of the NFL season.

We now have a two-game sample size of fantasy football data to work with from the 2022 NFL season.

It’s still a relatively small sample size, but trends are starting.

Before you make any roster cuts or waiver claims for Week 3, here are 10 utilization notes to know following Week 2.

Worth the risk? The Deshaun Watson outlook

Disciplinary uncertainty creates more questions than answers.

One of the ongoing questions heading into the “slow period” of the NFL – between OTAs and the start of training camps in late July – is the ongoing saga of Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson, who has made headlines off the field for the last 14 months.

Watson sat out the entire 2021 season, which was supposed to be the first year of four-year, $160 million extension he signed with the Houston Texans. An avalanche of civil lawsuits brought against him – most by massage therapists – claiming sexual assault or misconduct. A 23rd woman joined the lawsuit against Watson at the end of May, and No. 24 is reportedly expected to file come Monday.

However, when two grand juries failed to bring back a criminal indictment, the Texans saw an opportunity to trade their besieged signal-caller, and the Browns jumped at the opportunity to acquire a franchise quarterback better than Baker Mayfield.

Houston landed three first-round picks, a third-rounder in 2023, and a fourth-rounder in 2024 in exchange for Watson. If that investment by the Browns wasn’t enough, the team immediately announced that it tore up Watson’s contract with the Texans and replaced it with a five-year, $230 million deal with every dollar guaranteed.

Both sides of this strange, unsettling saga are unprecedented. On the football side of things, fully guaranteeing contracts has rarely been something NFL franchise do willingly. Nobody has ever committed this much in terms of guaranteed money – Watson’s guarantee was $80 million more than the previous high (Buffalo QB Josh Allen). It’s a field-tilter for quarterback salaries and guarantees that could set a standard many owners will look to avoid.

The other precedent-setting issue facing the NFL is the length of Watson’s anticipated suspension. Despite sitting out all of last season, Watson not subject to league discipline. Comparisons have been made to a 2010 suspension of Ben Roethlisberger, accused of sexually assaulting a 20-year-old Georgia college student at a nightclub. What made his six-game suspension (reduced to four games after Roethlisberger complied with numerous league-imposed stipulations) is that there were no criminal charges filed against him. Prior to that, the league waited until the legal process was completed before handing out its own punishment. Since Roethlisberger’s case, the NFL has suspended numerous players without criminal charges being filed.

What makes this case new to the NFL is Watson having been accused by 24 different women who make the same basic claim – just to varying degrees of misconduct. The NFL’s enforcement arm has a difficult decision to make after its own independent investigation. The league is still struggling with accusations of collusion against Colin Kaepernick and the offseason revelations in a lawsuit brought by Brian Flores.

Tired of losing your league every season? Be sure to sign up for The Huddle today to gain an award-winning edge on the competition! We have 26 years of experience online building fantasy football champions.

What sort of punishment do claims made by 24 different women warrant? Major League Baseball, typically the last pro sport to be proactive, recently doubled the established suspension limit of major sports by banning Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer for more than two years for allegations of sexual impropriety that also didn’t result in criminal charges.

The Browns have been taken off a lot of betting websites for wagers on the odds for Cleveland to win the AFC North, the AFC, and the Super Bowl, because everyone is waiting for the NFL to weigh on whether Watson will be suspended. It is expected that he will be, but the duration is anyone’s guess.

The suspension likely won’t be less than four games. Is six a possibility? Eight? Another full season?

All of those options are likely on the table. The uncertainty may be the reason the Browns didn’t accept a low-ball trade offer for Mayfield on draft weekend. Mayfield clearly isn’t Cleveland’s first choice – that was made painfully obvious – but he is the guy who has been the starter in Cleveland the last three years. Perhaps the fear of getting the worst-case scenario suspension for Watson is why Mayfield is still under contract with the Browns. Cleveland added veteran journeyman Jacoby Brissett in free agency a day after the Watson trade news broke, likely believing Mayfield wouldn’t be this difficult to trade away.

Fantasy football outlook

Watson’s fantasy football value for 2022 will be determined once the NFL weighs in on the matter and hands down its punishment.

Whatever the NFL decides, it is certain to face criticism for not handing down a stiff enough punishment given the gravity and sheer volume of the allegations. Until the league office delivers its judgment, the fate of the 2022 Browns will continue to remain in limbo.

Should Watson even be on your radar if you’re forced to draft prior to whenever that info is known? It depends upon a number of factors, such as scoring rules, league size, draft tendencies, and more, but the easiest way to frame it is as follows: Gamble on Watson only after about Round 11, and only if you have an established starter in case he winds up missing serious time. He has gone, on average, anywhere from Round 9 to 14 in drafts we’ve been apart of so far.

We’ll definitely provide more clarity upon the league’s ruling. What we know for sure is Watson enters a run-heavy offense with a so-so cast of aerial targets. He has excelled with worse at receiver, but there’s arguably more downside than potential for a strong season, regardless of how much time he may miss.

What to expect from the Washington Commanders backfield

How will Washington’s backfield shake out in fantasy football?

The Washington Commanders having a muddled backfield is nothing new. Difficulty predicting the main man has been normal the past few years, and often it wasn’t the back you thought it would be in August.

Trying to determine the impact of Commanders running backs Antonio Gibson, Brian Robinson Jr., J.D. McKissic and Jaret Patterson isn’t easy, but it does have a familiar ring.

When Washington drafted Gibson in 2020, he immediately became the primary back but was part of a platoon with McKissic and Peyton Barber. In 2021, Gibson had more than three times the carries as anyone else on the roster and responded with a 1,000-yard season. Things were looking up for Gibson to join the featured back fraternity.

Then Marty Hurney struck … again.

Hurney, the Commanders executive V.P. of player personnel, cut his front-office teeth as the Carolina Panthers general manager. He made headlines more than a decade earlier by doubling down on running backs. In the span of three drafts, he selected DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart – both in the first round.

Tired of losing your league every season? Be sure to sign up for The Huddle today to gain an award-winning edge on the competition! We have 26 years of experience online building fantasy football champions.

Fans remember how that turned out. Both posted strong numbers but were always viewed as a tandem. Both were drafted to be a RB1 in most formats, and both were formidable players, but they negated each other enough to become prone to having time-share stat lines too often.

You get the sense that the same is happening 14 years later in Washington. Two years into his career, the shifty, speedy Gibson is being joined a power runner to line up next to or at least behind him. There is very little subtlety about Robinson’s game. He’s a 230-pound power runner who attacks defenses and is yet another in a long list of Alabama running backs to transition to the NFL. Robinson waited his turn behind Bo Scarbrough, Josh Jacobs, Damien Harris and Najee Harris – the latter trio being currently viewed as three of the respective bell cow running backs for their franchises. Robinson is looking to be the next in line to quickly and successfully make the jump from ‘Bama to the NFL.

Complicating matters is that McKissic agreed in principle to a deal with the Buffalo Bills but backed out at the last minute and accepted a contract to stay with the Commanders. He carved out a role as a third-down receiving back, and his objective at this point is merely to hold on to that role.

The wild card here is Gibson’s penchant for fumbling, which can kill a fantasy player – especially when there are viable options to put that player in the coach’s doghouse for a game. In his first two seasons, Gibson has lost six fumbles. Washington didn’t really have the luxury of sitting him last year. With Robinson, they might.

Much in the same way the Panthers lit a fire under Williams by drafting Stewart, eventually Stewart kept earning more and more playing time and Williams had to learn to share the load. If one of them was injured, the other one thrived. But, the team was better off with the thunder-and-lightning combination they bring – even if it lessens their weekly numbers.

Fantasy football outlook

When it comes to putting a fantasy value on the top two Commanders running backs, it has all the earmarks of being a tale of two seasons. Gibson is going to get the benefit of the doubt early given Ron Rivera’s acknowledged loyalty to his veteran players. But, his fantasy value has already taken a hit with the arrival of Robinson. The rookie is likely to going to start the season on the low end of a 3-to-1 time share, but one of two things could change that as the season goes along.

The first could be that he forces the hand of the coaching staff by making the most of his opportunities – like Tony Pollard has done in Dallas. The other could be if Gibson’s fumbling remains an issue. Injury, of course, is a third path, but players tend not to lose their role to minor ailments.

For the yearlong fantasy numbers, the money is on Gibson. He still has RB2 value, but when you need fantasy wins in December, Robinson may be more valuable at that point – especially at a discount price on draft night. The rookie is a must-handcuff for Gibson owners and also has RB4 worth in his own right. McKissic serves as viable roster depth in PPR leagues but offers little beyond the occasional flex play out of desperation.

Fantasy Football Market Report: Week 5

One month into the NFL and fantasy football season, some players are moving up the charts quickly while others are near rock bottom.

We are in a transition season in the NFL. Whether it was COVID-19 that kept teams from building up to the regular season or simply the tipping point of games being predominantly high-scoring, what has happened through four weeks in the 2020 NFL is startling and unprecedented.

Teams are routinely scoring 30 points or more – at a record-setting pace.

To put it in perspective, in the previous five seasons – four of those consisting of 63 games because of the start of bye season and one with 64 – there was a consistency to how many teams would have a high-scoring game of 30+ points. From 2015-19, through four weeks of the season, the numbers of teams who scored 30 or more in a game was a near-flat line (30-32-28-33-28). That’s crazy consistent.

Heading into Monday’s Atlanta-Green Bay game, there had been 62 games played. In those games, 51 teams scored 30 or more points in a game. Green Bay became the 52nd when they dropped 30 points on Atlanta.

In the previous five years, it tended to be only one team that scored 30+. Of the 151 teams that scored 30 or more, they won 85 percent of the games (128-23).

Last year, if you scored 30 in Weeks 1-4, you had a winning percentage of more than 89 percent (25-3). This year? Teams scoring 30 or more points won 39 games, but 12 who also scored 30 have lost. That’s an average of three games a week in which both teams hit that lofty number and they combined to have a winning percentage of 76.5 percent.

Is it a sign of the times? Is it a sign of no training camp or preseason that has given offenses the clear edge to move the ball? All fantasy players know is that points are up and they like it that way…unless the bomb drops on them.

Here is the Week 5 Fantasy Market Report:

Fantasy Football Risers

Dak Prescott, QB, Dallas Cowboys

There’s a strange simpatico fantasy owners have with Dallas quarterbacks. Guys didn’t love Tony Romo, but drafted him every year because they wished for Dallas to fall behind by double digits early and it was game-on for garbage points trying to come back.

Over the last three weeks, Prescott has thrown for an ungodly 1,424 yards with eight touchdown passes and three TD runs. His pass-yardage total has been 450, 472 and 502. Who cares if his team sucks. He’s taking fantasy owners to the pay window all by himself.

Kareem Hunt, RB, Cleveland Browns

Sometimes Dame Fortune smiles on a guy. In 2017, I was in three leagues. The only player I had in all of them was Hunt. He was incredible. His career took a major backward step, but, as the clear No. 2 guy in Cleveland – he hasn’t had more than 17 touches in a game – he has managed to rush for 275 yards and has scored five touchdowns in his last three games.

With Nick Chubb down for a month or more, Hunt has every chance to relive his eye-popping rookie season.

Tom Brady, QB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

The word, as it has been every time Brady has struggled in the first couple of games, was that he was washed up. He’s hit the wall. In his first two games with the Bucs, he didn’t hit 240 yards, had as many interceptions (3) as touchdowns and had a passer rating under 80.0.

In the last two games? 666 passing yards (make what you want out of that) with eight touchdowns, one pick and a passer rating over 116.0. Seems like the Brady we remember…again.

D.K. Metcalf, WR, Seattle Seahawks

If consistency is what you’re looking for, look no further. In four games, he has caught four passes in each. That would be reason for benching in a lot of leagues. But, he has yardage totals of 95, 92, 110 and 106. He has averaged 23 yards a catch or better in every game (25.2 overall) and has scored a touchdown in three of four games.

Metcalf is going to be a superstar and won’t be had as reasonably as he has been his first two season on fantasy draft day. Russ is going to get him paid – whether with Seattle or somewhere else.

Antonio Gibson, RB, Washington Football Team

This is a sneaky play designed for being an option when bye weeks hit. He hasn’t rushed for more than 55 yards in any game, but his carry-share has been going up significantly. He has scored a rushing touchdown in each of the last three games and his competition in the Washington backfield is quickly disappearing, while his is stock is going up.

Nobody with other viable options will start Gibson, but he could be nice to have on your roster as a throw-in on a trade to stash in case COVID times get desperate.

Fantasy Football Fallers

Josh Jacobs, RB, Oakland Raiders

Jacobs was selected on fantasy rosters to be that owner’s No. 1 running back. When he rushed for three touchdowns in Week 1, he was locked into lineups regardless of what followed. Since then, his rushing attempts have dropped (27-16-15), his yardage has dropped (88-71-48), he is little more than a check-down receiver and he hasn’t scored a touchdown. You can’t bench him because of his role in the Vegas offense. You may want to. You just can’t.

DeSean Jackson, WR, Philadelphia Eagles

Jackson is a polarizing player. By any measure, he should have Julian Edelman-style reception numbers, yet he has never been able to be anything more than a one-trick pony. And, in his second run in Philadelphia, he’s been cashing checks and showing nothing. A quarter of the way through the season, he has 10 catches for 121 yards, no touchdowns and is nursing an injury. If you have him on your roster, cut him or trade him immediately. He’s taking up space that could be better utilized by someone else.

Evan Engram, TE, New York Giants

In leagues in which tight ends are mandatory, there have been a lot of big days posted along the way. Not by Engram. He is the Giants leading receiver in terms of targets (30) and catches (17), but he’s Marcedes Lewis 2.0.

For all his athleticism and talent, he averaged 7.7 yards a catch with only one of more than 12 yards and has no touchdowns. Those in TE-required leagues likely aren’t benching him, but they’re getting beat in their weekly position battles by their opponents because Engram is giving them scraps.

David Montgomery, RB, Chicago Bears

Montgomery was one of those guys in draft rankings that was expected to become an elite fantasy back. You shook the Magic 8-Ball. “All Signs Point to Yes.”

The Bears have been playing light’s out defense, which typically gets a running back a lot of play. But, through four games, Montgomery has just 53 carries for 218 yards and no touchdowns – and 24-72-0 rushing numbers over the last two – and his only touchdown was on a check-down pass that broke wide open. He was drafted to be an NFL RB1, but hasn’t showed it.

Irv Smith, TE, Minnesota Vikings

When Minnesota drafted Smith last year, the thought was that he would take over the role Kyle Rudolph has as one of the most potent Red Zone tight ends in the league. Instead, through four games, Smith has been healthy, but targeted just six times, catching two passes for 14 yards and no touchdowns. He’s rendered himself unplayable and, at this point, most people who took a flyer on him have bailed.