East dominates East West Matches 31½-13½ at Maridoe Golf Club

The Ryder Cup-style event combines three generations of amateur golf talent from across the U.S.

CARROLTON, Texas — The second playing of the East West Matches concluded Sunday afternoon with the East completing a wire-to-wire win.

The Ryder Cup-style event is the brainchild of mid-am Scott Harvey and Maridoe Golf Club owner and oil tycoon Albert Hudleston. Combining three generations of amateur golf talent from across the U.S., the East West Matches is one of the most talent-laden events in all of amateur golf.

Looking to avenge a painful loss in the first playing of the Matches, the East through two days was replicating what it did in 2020. 

Friday saw the East jump out to a 6-3 lead in four-ball before the skies burst open and drenched the course with more than an inch and a half of rain. With the course softened up and true rolling greens, the East picked up another 11 ½ points during Saturday’s marathon 36-hole foursomes matches.

Leading 17 ½ – 9 ½, captain Nathaniel Crosby’s team needed just 5 ½ singles wins to defeat the West and avenge the loss from two years ago.

Did the East deliver.

In the 18 singles matches Sunday, 14 of them were won by the East and only seven even made it to the 18th hole. Joe Deraney of the East squad looked at the leaderboard while watching his teammates come through the par-3 14th and smiled.

“It’s not like last time,” he said.

Blowing a double-digit lead Sunday in 2020, you could tell that Deraney and others that were on that team wanted so badly to claim the victory and make up for that meltdown.

The East surrendered just three matches to the West and split two more. The 14-4 drubbing resulted in a final score of 31 ½ – 13 ½ and gives the East its first win in the infancy of the event.

So what’s the secret to having a team pull out a lopsided win when the talent gap is practically nonexistent? Crosby gave a veteran tip from his multiple Walker Cup captaincies: “I think it was the 3 a.m. curfew that probably was the detail (that did it),” Crosby joked. “The mandatory two hours of sleep for each player, each night. … you have to think it through.”

All kidding aside, the week is more about what amateur golf is truly about:  comradery.

“The coolest part about this tournament is you’re putting three generations together,” Crosby said. “Generational friendships are absolutely the best to have. The college kids being able to play with the mid-ams and the mid-ams playing with the seniors, bridging these generations is such a great format. Everybody had such a blast.”

Crosby’s crew will look to defend in 2024 when the East West Matches take place once again at Maridoe.

As for what’s next, a large handful of mid-amateurs and senior amateurs from the East West Matches, including Golfweek’s No. 1 ranked senior, Rusty Strawn, will be heading to Spain for next week’s Concession Cup.

Team rosters

Mid-Amateurs

East: Andrew Bailey, Evan Beck, Chip Brooke, Mark Costanza, Joe Deraney, Jeronimo Esteve, Scott Harvey, Matt Mattare, Tug Maude, Chad Wilfong

West: Jason Anthony, Skip Berkmeyer, Denny Bull, Derek Busby, Patrick Christovich, Nick Guyer, Colby Harwell, John Hunter, Brad Nurski, John Swain

Senior Amateurs

East: Doug Hanzel, Steve Harwell, Billy Mitchell, Bob Royak, Rusty Strawn, Matt Sughrue

West: Tommy Brennan, Jon Brown, Robert Funk, John McClure, Mike McCoy, Mike Rowley

Amateurs

East: Nick Dunlap (Alabama), Caleb Surratt (Tennessee)

West: Derek Hitchner (Pepperdine), Luke Potter (Arizona State)

[mm-video type=playlist id=01es6rjnsp3c84zkm6 player_id=01evcfxp4q8949fs1e image=https://golfweek.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Is this the best amateur golf event you’ve never heard of? The second East West Matches should bring fireworks

The East West Matches bring together some of the best amateurs, mid-ams and senior amateurs in the United States.

In its infancy, the East West Matches is maybe the best amateur golf event you’ve never heard of.

The second playing of the event is set to tee off this weekend, Nov. 4-6.

The brainchild of two-time USGA champion and former Walker Cup participant Scott Harvey, the East West Matches combine some of the best amateurs, mid-ams and senior amateurs in the United States. The Ryder Cup-style event features two amateur players, six senior amateurs and 10 mid-amateur players per side.

The matches are back at Maridoe Golf Club in Carrollton, Texas, where the inaugural Cup was won in dramatic fashion by the West in 2020. In fact, the man that clinched the winning half-point for the West, Patrick Christovich, is back to help the West defend their title. 

Captained by 2005 U.S. Mid-Am champion, Kevin Marsh, the West has experience under pressure on its side. Returning Skip Berkmeyer, Derek Busby, Patrick Christovich, Brad Nurski and Robert Funk, the West is armed with a crew that went 9-9-1 and was a large part of the West’s monstrous 23-22 comeback win back in 2020.

In addition, the West has two amateur players ranked inside the top 110 in the World Amateur Golf Rankings — Pepperdine’s Derek Hitchner and Arizona State’s Luke Potter are ranked Nos. 105 and 38 in WAGR, respectively. The two should give a spark of energy to their mid-am and senior-am teammates.

The West celebrates its 23-22 comeback win over the East at the inaugural East West Matches (2020) at Maridoe Golf Club in Carrollton, Texas.

On the East side, there’s a sense of hunger and redemption. The East is also returning five players from their 2020 team. A murderer’s row of amateur golf talent that had a combined 2020 record of 15-4-1 but left Maridoe empty-handed.

Joe Deraney, Jeronimo Esteve, Scott Harvey, Doug Hanzel and Bob Royak look to take down the West this year and stake claim to what they came so close to having two years ago. The strength of the East team lies in both seniors and young gun amateurs.

Both Hanzel and Royak went 4-0-0 in the 2020 Matches. Now they bolster their lineup even more with the addition of Golfweek’s No. 1 ranked senior amateur Rusty Strawn. Tried and true, the colts in the East’s stable of talent are Alabama’s Nick Dunlap and Tennessee’s Caleb Surratt.

Dunlap was Golfweek’s No. 1 ranked recruit in the 2022 class and the 2021 AJGA Boys Golfer of the Year. Surratt is currently ranked No. 15 in WAGR and is the 2022 U.S. Junior Amateur runner-up.

Who’s running the stable for the East, you ask? That would be two-time Walker Cup captain Nathaniel Crosby.

The East has brought out the big guns, but will they be able to redeem themselves after such a disappointing finish in 2020? 

Time will tell and if we learned anything from the inaugural East West Matches, we know that anything can happen over the course of three days at Maridoe Golf Club.

Full Rosters

Mid-Amateurs

East: Andrew Bailey, Evan Beck, Chip Brooke, Mark Costanza, Joe Deraney, Jeronimo Esteve, Scott Harvey, Matt Mattare, Tug Maude, Chad Wilfong

West: Jason Anthony, Skip Berkmeyer, Denny Bull, Derek Busby, Patrick Christovich, Nick Guyer, Colby Harwell, John Hunter, Brad Nurski, John Swain

Senior Amateurs

East: Doug Hanzel, Steve Harwell, Billy Mitchell, Bob Royak, Rusty Strawn, Matt Sughrue

West: Tommy Brennan, Jon Brown, Robert Funk, John McClure, Mike McCoy, Mike Rowley

Amateurs

East: Nick Dunlap (Alabama) & Caleb Surratt (Tennessee)

West: Derek Hitchner (Pepperdine) & Luke Potter (Arizona State)

[listicle id=778291775]

[mm-video type=playlist id=01es6rjnsp3c84zkm6 player_id=none image=https://golfweek.usatoday.com/wp-content/plugins/mm-video/images/playlist-icon.png]

Introducing the East West Matches: This week’s best team game is going down at Maridoe

The East West Matches, which will pit top amateurs from either coast against each other, will debut this week at Maridoe Golf Club.

Skip Berkmeyer doesn’t know what it feels like to be on a Ryder Cup team – or a Walker Cup team. That ship has probably sailed for the 46-year-old from St. Louis. But Berkmeyer’s ears perked up in 2019 when Scott Harvey, a former U.S. Mid-Amateur champion, voiced an idea that would mimic the concept.

Why not create a biannual team event within the U.S. for amateurs? Battle lines were drawn up the Mississippi River and the East West Matches were born.

“I was like man, I want to play. I want to be on that first team,” Berkmeyer said. “To make the team you have to play good golf, so that was a goal then. . . . It was always on my mind since he brought it up and we talked about it.”

Berkmeyer has played a supporting role in the creation of an event that Harvey, 42, ultimately brought to life. Similar ideas for a match pitting the most competitive amateurs, in all age brackets, against each other had stalled out at least twice before. A year and a half ago, Harvey decided it was time to make it happen.

“Mid-amateur golf has so many good players,” he reasoned. “It just felt like the right time to do it.”

The East West Matches will debut Nov. 6-8 at Maridoe Golf Club in Carrollton, Texas. The 18 best amateurs from east of the Mississippi will take on those from west of it in a mix of fourball, foursomes and singles matches.

Paul Simson and Tim Jackson will captain the East team while Jim Holtgrieve and Kevin Marsh will captain the West team. That’s a foursome with USGA starts in the triple-digits, and long resumes past that. They’ll be responsible for setting pairings before each of the three days of play – ideally in the most raucous way possible. The only caveat? No two players on any team can partner more than once.

“One captain is going to put up a pairing and then the other captain is going to match it with whoever he wants,” Harvey explained, “and let the trash talking begin, right?”

https://www.instagram.com/p/CHLYv4nFK3W/

There are several chapters to this conception story, from Harvey’s initial push to the conversations about details – like team selection and format – to the week in July 2019 when Harvey played the Trans-Miss Championship at Maridoe and struck up a conversation with owner Albert Huddleston about making Maridoe the host site. The matches will come back there every other year.

Other voices emerged along the way, like that of David Nelson, a USGA committee member and a stiff player, who tried to bring a similar event to fruition at Bandon Dunes in 2001. It slid off the calendar after the Sept. 11 attacks and never was revived.

Nelson dug up old notes, invitations and logos for Harvey. They talked through Harvey’s new concept while playing the same tournament last fall.

Nelson, who qualified for the 1982 U.S. Open, among many other events, still plays, but he won’t travel to Maridoe this year. He’s already running the numbers on how he could qualify for future matches.

When Nelson, a longtime Nevada resident who recently moved to the Denver suburbs upon retirement, was trying to get the event off the ground in the early 2000s, part of the motivation was to address what he saw as a Walker Cup selection process skewed toward East Coast players as opposed to West Coast players.

“That was the main reason I was trying to get these East West Cup Matches, to showcase the West Coast guys against the East Coast guys and show that hey, we’ve got a lot of really good players out here,” Nelson said.

Recent Walker Cup squads have since had strong West Coast representation. In fact 2016 U.S. Mid-Amateur champion Stewart Hagestad, of Newport Beach, California, played on the last two teams. He’ll play this week on the West squad.

The time is now

After Brett Boner finished runner-up at the 2018 U.S. Mid-Amateur, it was like the door to an underground society opened. On a normal year, there’s no shortage of tournaments for mid-amateurs to play, all over the country.

Boner, 46, competed in the Coleman Invitational (Seminole Golf Club), Thomas Invitational (Los Angeles Country Club), Crump Cup (Pine Valley) and Jones Cup (Ocean Forest GC in Sea Island, Georgia) the next year and played both the 2019 and 2020 U.S. Amateurs.

He heaped the pressure on himself in those starts, though, and some of it had to do with his inability to close out Kevin O’Connell at the Mid-Amateur – played in his hometown of Charlotte. It has been a tough loss to get over.

“I was right there, I was playing good enough golf,” he said. “At this age, you kind of think, how many more opportunities are you going to get?”

https://www.instagram.com/p/CG7PVWKFRti/

The pandemic cut into the mid-amateur tournament circuit in 2020, which was a bit of a welcome break. The East West Matches “should be a total blast,” Boner says. They will be a little lighter. They will be about the connections in a pocket of the game into which Boner has been welcomed with open arms.

Boner lit up when he got the call from Harvey that he’d made the East team.

“I said Scott, when I was a kid I dreamed of playing in the Ryder Cup, and this is the closest thing I’ll ever get.”

And that’s the idea.

In designing the event, Harvey, Berkmeyer & Co., had several conversations about state events, the Walker Cup (Harvey played for the U.S. in 2015) and the Ryder Cup. The East West Matches always went back to that concept. But if there’s something they hope to prioritize the most, it’s relationships.

“Just the camaraderie of it all,” Harvey said. “Everybody seems to come together.”

The golf, Harvey says, is secondary.

“I think the best thing you want to do in golf is to have respect of your peers,” said Berkmeyer. “To go and get invited to this, to play in it and hopefully play well in it, whatever the result, that’s what you want to be a part of in the game of golf.”

https://www.instagram.com/p/CHL07APATvX/

You got options, kids

Four men in the field will come at this week from a different perspective. The East team includes U.S. Amateur winner Tyler Strafaci as well as John Pak, low amateur at the 2020 U.S. Open. Southern Amateur champion Mac Meissner and Western Amateur champion Pierceson Coody will play for the West.

Harvey recognizes that players of that caliber – and age – heighten the draw of the event. Younger players were always in the equation when Harvey was dreaming up these matches, he just didn’t know exactly who the players would be. He hopes they’re paying attention this week.

“This is the thought process: It’s a way to say if you turn pro, or even if you don’t turn pro, and things don’t work out, you can still play golf,” Harvey said. “There’s still things to play for, they don’t have to quit. This is an introduction to that world.”

None of the twentysomethings have had a normal college season because of COVID. None of the mid-amateur or senior players in the matches have lived a normal 2020, either. In that respect, this event couldn’t come at a better time.

“I think of all the years in mid-amateur or amateur golf that we need this event,” Berkmeyer said, “this is it.”

[lawrence-related id=778072613,778054524,778048254]