1. Super Bowl XLVI
How else would this list have possibly ended? The Lombardi always means the most.
Four years removed from upsetting the then-perfect New England Patriots, the Giants again came face-to-face with Tom Brady & Co., who were determined to exact revenge.
They didn’t.
Although not as exciting as Super Bowl XLII, the championship rematch between New York and New England was an electric nail-biter from start to finish.
The highlight? A late fourth quarter throw from Eli Manning to Mario Manningham, which is arguably the greatest throw in Giants history and Super Bowl history, and one of the greatest throws in NFL history.
Ahmad Bradshaw’s anti-climactic backwards touchdown late in the game aside, it’s hard not to find thrill in reliving another Giant dent in the Patriots’ legendary dynasty.